gaents Dashboard

TTS / Voice Synthesis

Category id ed2e56cedb57a949 (derived from Scout's category name (no id in Scout's data)). 19 alternatives, shown in Scout's order.

Our own measured runs

No head-to-head measured in this category yet.

Alternatives

Chatterbox TTS

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Chatterbox is Resemble AI's open-source flagship TTS built on a 350M-parameter S3/Turbo backbone with a diffusion-style decoder, released under MIT. It performs zero-shot voice cloning from a 5-10 second reference clip, exposes an explicit emotion/exaggeration slider that most other open models lack, and ships with a Perth watermarker baked into every output so downstream detection is possible. Generation runs... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/resemble-ai/chatterbox Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
LicenceMIT Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
PriceFree self-hosted as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars27828 as of 2026-11-09 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout patch_history (github_stars changed)
Last commit2026-11-04 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Two-year cost (GBP)~£550-950 over 2 years. Our current VPS has no usable GPU, so we either (a) add a used RTX 3060 12GB (~£220 one-off) or (b) rent Vast.ai RTX 3060 ~£0.08/hr * 15 hrs/month = £14/month = £336 over 2 years. Electricity on (a) ~£70. Against ElevenLabs Creator at $22/month (~£840 over 2 years), Chatterbox saves £300-1,300 with payback in month 1-3. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified

Scout's judgement

Verdict
adopt-now
Conclusion
Install this as our primary narration engine for demo videos once we stand up a GPU worker — it is the only open model that credibly matches ElevenLabs on English expressiveness, has a clean MIT license, and saves £300-1,300 over 2 years. The only real gating item is the GPU.
Limits for us
English is strongly SoTA but non-English languages are weak in the base model. Hard GPU requirement (CPU inference unusable) is the biggest blocker for our VPS-only infra. Cloning quality degrades on reference clips shorter than 8s, noisy references, or strong non-US accents. Mandatory Perth watermark is inaudible but a compliance consideration if we distribute audio to partners running watermark scans. Long-form narration (>30s) needs manual chunking. Licence is clean MIT — commercial demo video use is unambiguously fine.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
3
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.9

Credited to Scout (2026-11-09, Scout last_verified). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

Best quality open-source TTS. Zero-shot voice cloning from 10s audio. 350M Turbo model. 6-8 GB VRAM. MOS ~4.3. pip install chatterbox-tts. Gradio UI + FastAPI server available. CUDA, ROCm, CPU. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from LICENSE (MIT); self_hostable and api_or_webhooks from README (pip library); data_export n/a (model).] [2026-11-09T08:48Z cloud refresh: Tweet triage 2026-11-04 #2 (2026-11-09): gh api 27,694 stars, pushed 2026-11-04; licence MIT unchanged.]

Kokoro TTS

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Kokoro-82M is a tiny 82-million-parameter StyleTTS2-derived model from hexgrad, Apache-2.0 licensed, that ranked #1 on TTS Arena in January 2026 despite being 4-10x smaller than its competitors. It ships with ~50 pre-baked voices across English (US/UK), Japanese, Mandarin, Spanish, French, Hindi, Italian and Portuguese, and crucially has no native zero-shot cloning — you pick a voice, you don't clone one.... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/hexgrad/kokoro Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
LicenceApache-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
PriceFree as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars10120 as of 2026-11-09 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout patch_history (github_stars changed)
Last commit2025-08-06 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Two-year cost (GBP)~£0-50 over 2 years. Kokoro runs on our existing CPU-only VPS with no hardware changes, no GPU rental, and no new electricity cost. The only real cost is ~20 hours of setup time to pick voices and write ffmpeg glue. Against ElevenLabs Creator at £840 over 2 years, Kokoro is effectively the full avoided cost — £840-1,880 saved. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified

Scout's judgement

Verdict
adopt-now
Conclusion
Install this today as the default narration engine for every non-hero demo video — it is the only option that runs on our existing CPU-only VPS with zero hardware changes and a permissive licence, and the quality is good enough for 80% of narration work. Pair it with Chatterbox for the 20% of scripts that need cloned voices.
Limits for us
The hard limit is no voice cloning — if we ever need Adam's voice or a specific agent-persona voice, Kokoro cannot do it. Locked to the 50 shipped voices. Expressive range is good-but-not-great: it lacks the emotional punch Chatterbox gets from its exaggeration slider. Long-form (>1 minute monologue) benefits from chunking. Non-English voices are newer and rougher than English. No licence risk — Apache-2.0, commercial use explicitly fine.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
2
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.7

Credited to Scout (2026-11-09, Scout last_verified). gaents does not score items.

Scout tested it (proven, 2026-09-14): Voice-A candidate for the Bitcoin Turing-Complete V3 explainer (150 s narration). RUN BY VIDEO, not by Scout — recorded here from Video's 2026-09-14-bitcoin-v3-bakeoff-research.md and Scout's tool menu that extends it.

Scout's notes

Tiny model (82M), runs on CPU. 96x real-time on GPU. 50 built-in voices. No native voice cloning (community forks add it). Best efficiency. pip install kokoro. [2026-10-19T22:08Z cloud refresh: Q4-2026 review: abandonment rule hit. Last commit on hexgrad/kokoro is 2025-08-06; last PyPI release 0.9.4 on 2025-04-05; HF Kokoro-82M last modified 2025-04-10. Over 12 months with no release or commit. Agent judgement: still usable (Apache-2.0, works on CPU), so moved from adopt-now to adopt, not lower; pin the version. No better or cheaper alternative cited: DB has maintained TTS entries but I found no official evidence one beats free Kokoro.] [2026-10-19T22:09Z Scout: verdict restored to adopt-now; the downgrade used a 12-month staleness literal from Scout's own prompt, now withdrawn (de-assume). Last-release date kept as a fact in patch_history.] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from LICENSE (Apache-2.0); self_hostable and api_or_webhooks from README (inference library); data_export n/a (model). Last commit 2025-08-06 (fact only).]

F5-TTS

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

F5-TTS from SWivid (Shanghai Jiao Tong University) is a non-autoregressive flow-matching TTS built on a DiT (Diffusion Transformer) backbone with a ConvNeXt V2 text encoder, ~330M parameters, released MIT. Its headline feature is good zero-shot English voice cloning from a short reference plus reference text, and its flow-matching architecture means it generates in a single forward pass rather than... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/SWivid/F5-TTS Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceMIT (code); CC-BY-NC (pre-trained models) Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classsource-available Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars15588 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-03 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)~£400-800 over 2 years. Same GPU-worker problem as Chatterbox: ~£220 for a used 3060 12GB or ~£336 for 2 years of light Vast.ai rental. Slightly lower VRAM ceiling means we could get away with a cheaper 8GB card (~£150 used). Avoided ElevenLabs cost is the same £840-1,880 over 2 years. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence terms on use (flagged by Scout)pretrained weights CC-BY-NC (code MIT) Scout, gaents-proven-2026-11-18.md A22026-11-18Scout review date

Scout's judgement

Verdict
evaluate
Conclusion
Skip in favour of Chatterbox for our specific need — F5-TTS is excellent but Chatterbox beats it on English expressiveness and on workflow simplicity, and the GPU tradeoff is the same. Keep on the 'evaluate' shelf as a fallback if Chatterbox has licence or quality regressions.
Limits for us
The reference-text requirement is real workflow friction: cloning a voice requires both audio AND a matching transcript, which Chatterbox does not need. Emotion control is noticeably weaker than Chatterbox. Same hard GPU requirement as Chatterbox. Licence is clean MIT.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
4
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.8

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

Best voice cloning fidelity among lightweight models. ~330M params. Quantized: 400MB VRAM. RTF 0.15 (paper). Good for precise voice matching. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: Correction: stored license 'MIT' covers only the code; README says the pre-trained models are CC-BY-NC, so license corrected. licence_class source-available (agent-chose: the usable TTS model is non-commercial; code is MIT). type left as stored for Scout. self_hostable and api_or_webhooks from README pip install (Python package/CLI); data_export n/a (model).]

Dia TTS (Nari Labs)

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

1.6B-param multi-speaker dialogue TTS. Apache 2.0. 19.2k stars. Generates realistic multi-speaker conversation in single pass. Requires 10GB+ VRAM NVIDIA GPU. (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/nari-labs/dia Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceApache-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars19408 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2025-11-19 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)0 GBP (Apache 2.0). GPU infra: 0-1,920 GBP depending on hosting. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
watch
Conclusion
Leading dialogue TTS but voice consistency and cloning issues make it unreliable. Worth watching for multi-speaker needs.
Limits for us
TTS not core. GPU required. Voice consistency issues. Poor cloning quality. English only.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
4
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.5

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

1.6B params. 10GB VRAM (quantized: 4GB). Specializes in multi-speaker dialogue. Voice cloning via audio conditioning. Good for conversational demo videos with two speakers. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2025-11-19; licence unchanged (Apache-2.0).]

Orpheus TTS

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Orpheus TTS by Canopy AI is an open-source text-to-speech system that produces human-like prosody with features including zero-shot voice cloning, emotion and intonation controls, and low-latency streaming at around a few hundred milliseconds. The model generates natural, expressive speech using a neural TTS backbone and emphasizes prosody, rhythm, and emotion in delivery. It supports cloning voices without... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/canopyai/Orpheus-TTS Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceApache-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars6404 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2025-12-05 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)Free (open source). Compute costs for GPU inference: GBP 30-100/month for a dedicated GPU server capable of real-time synthesis. 2-year total: GBP 720-2,400 in compute. Could run on existing GPU infrastructure if available. No per-request or licensing fees. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
evaluate
Conclusion
Orpheus TTS offers impressive open-source voice synthesis with zero-shot cloning, but is blocked by our pending GPU infrastructure decision. Once GPU capacity is available, it becomes a strong evaluate candidate alongside Chatterbox and Kokoro.
Limits for us
Requires GPU for real-time inference — our VPS fleet may not have dedicated GPU capacity (Adam GPU decision still pending). Quality varies by language, gender, and acoustic conditions. Blocked on action readiness due to GPU infrastructure dependency. Some complex speech still sounds synthetic. Integration with our agent stack would need custom work. Not yet as polished as commercial offerings like ElevenLabs for production voice applications.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
6
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.5

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

3B params. 15-24GB VRAM. Best-in-class emotional expression (laughter, pauses, emotion). Uses vLLM backend. 8 built-in voices. Overkill for narration but excellent for character voices. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from LICENSE (Apache-2.0, code); self_hostable/api from README (Python package); data_export n/a (model).]

Fish Speech

source-availablenot runnable on gaents yet

Fish Speech (fishaudio / 39 AI, Inc.) is a dual-autoregressive-transformer TTS with a grouped-query attention backbone and a VQ-GAN vocoder, currently at v1.5 with ~500M effective params. It supports zero-shot voice cloning from a short reference, strong multilingual coverage across English, Chinese, Japanese, German, French, Spanish, Korean and Arabic, and reported MOS ~4.1 on internal evaluations. It is the... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/fishaudio/fish-speech Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceFish Audio Community License Agreement v1.0 (last updated 2026-10-13): free research/non-commercial use; commercial use free only while Annual Revenue < USD 500,000; Hosted Service always needs a separate licence Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classsource-available Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typesource-available Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree self-hosted (base), S2 Pro needs enterprise GPU as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars33724 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-14 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)Unknown but potentially expensive. Research licence is £0, but commercial licence required for demo videos is a negotiated bespoke contract — typical TTS commercial research-licence deals run £2,000-£20,000/year. Even at £1,000/year that's £2,000 over 2 years — worse than ElevenLabs Creator (£840), far worse than Kokoro (£0) or Chatterbox (~£550-950). Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
consider
Conclusion
Skip for production demo video narration — the custom research licence explicitly excludes commercial use and negotiating a bespoke commercial licence makes it more expensive than ElevenLabs.
Limits for us
Licence (Fish Audio Community License v1.0, 2026-10-13): commercial use is free only while annual revenue (with affiliates) is under USD 500,000; offering a hosted TTS/voice-cloning service is never licensed. Whether ukacq is under the threshold is ❓ OPEN (Adam). Needs a CUDA GPU (~4-6 GB VRAM fp16).
Lock-in risk
medium
Integration hours (estimate)
5
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.75

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout tested it (blocked, 2026-09-14): SKIP ANCHOR. Re-verified the licence so that a future agent reading the star count (32,687 — the highest in the TTS category) does not re-propose it.

Scout's notes

~500M base. 4GB VRAM base model. Zero-shot cloning (10-30s ref). Custom license — verify commercial use. S2 Pro needs 24GB+. [2026-10-19T23:00Z cloud refresh: [2026-10-19 licence check] Licence changed since the 2026-09-14 check. Repo LICENSE (last changed in commit 2026-10-14) is now 'FISH AUDIO COMMUNITY LICENSE AGREEMENT Version 1.0 — Last Updated: October 13, 2026', replacing the Fish Audio Research License. New: a Community Commercial License while the licensee's Annual Revenue (with Affiliates) is under USD 500,000; a Hosted Service (TTS/voice cloning for third parties) is never licensed. Whether ukacq is under the threshold is ❓ OPEN. type set to source-available under Scout ruling 1. Verdict not changed here. CONFIRMED.] [2026-10-20T01:32Z cloud refresh: Verdict skip -> consider on licence evidence (not age): the skip was set under the old Research/Non-Commercial licence; the 2026-10-13 licence allows commercial use under a revenue threshold. Quoted as facts; the threshold question is Adam's.] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2026-10-14; licence unchanged (Fish Audio Community License Agreement v1.0).]

Coqui XTTS v2

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Coqui XTTS v2 is an open-source text-to-speech model that enables high-quality voice cloning and cross-language synthesis from a short reference sample of approximately 6 seconds. It supports 17+ languages and can generate speech in multiple languages from the same model. The model features emotion and style transfer for expressive speech alongside standard neutral synthesis. Architecture uses text tokenisation,... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/coqui-ai/TTS Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceMPL-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classcopyleft Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars46227 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2024-08-16 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)Free (open source). GPU compute for inference: GBP 30-100/month. 2-year total: GBP 720-2,400 in compute. No licensing fees. Can run on consumer GPUs. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
skip
Conclusion
Coqui XTTS v2 has impressive voice cloning capabilities but the company shutdown and uncertain maintenance future make it risky. Our existing TTS selections (Chatterbox + Kokoro) are safer choices.
Limits for us
Coqui company shut down — project is community-maintained with uncertain long-term viability. We already selected Chatterbox + Kokoro as our TTS solution. GPU dependency (same as Orpheus). Voice cloning quality inconsistent across use cases. Python-only ecosystem may not integrate well with all our agent toolchains. Our TTS decision is already made and this option has higher risk due to the company shutdown.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
3
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.7

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout tested it (untested-by-scout, 2026-09-14): SKIP ANCHOR. Re-verified abandonment so that a future agent reading the star count (46,011 — second highest in the category) does not re-propose it.

Scout's notes

467M params. 4-8GB VRAM. Best-documented voice cloning (6s ref audio). Company shut down Jan 2024 — community-maintained. Quality ceiling lower than Chatterbox/Kokoro. Dependency issues increasing. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2024-02-10; licence unchanged (MPL-2.0).]

Piper TTS

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Piper is an open-source, local neural text-to-speech system designed for offline operation on devices as small as Raspberry Pi. It uses ONNX-based voice models to produce natural-sounding speech with realistic prosody. The system supports multi-speaker voices, configurable voice selection, and integrates as a TTS backend for Rhasspy and similar home automation platforms. It outputs WAV audio from input text with... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/rhasspy/piper Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceMIT Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars11330 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2025-08-26 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)Free (open source). No compute costs beyond existing hardware. Runs on CPU, no GPU required. 2-year total: GBP 0. Voice models are freely downloadable. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
skip
Conclusion
Piper is excellent for lightweight, offline TTS but our adopt-now stack already includes superior TTS options (Chatterbox + Kokoro). Piper's CPU-only operation is a pro but voice quality trails the alternatives we selected.
Limits for us
We already identified Chatterbox + Kokoro as our TTS solution in the adopt-now stack, with Orpheus TTS as a GPU-dependent alternative. Piper's quality is lower than neural TTS models like Orpheus or Chatterbox but it runs on CPU. Voice quality varies by language and model. Limited to pre-trained voices — no zero-shot cloning. Best suited for home automation/accessibility rather than production voice applications. Our TTS decision is already made.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
2
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.3

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

CPU-only, fastest TTS (RTF <0.05). Pre-trained voices only — no cloning. Good but slightly robotic. Best for real-time/embedded, not broadcast narration. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2025-08-26; licence unchanged (MIT). Repo archived 2025-10-06. README: "Development has moved: https://github.com/OHF-Voice/piper1-gpl". Verdict already skip, no change. Candidate add (not added): OHF-Voice/piper1-gpl (name says GPL; licence not read here).]

Qwen3-TTS

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Alibaba's TTS with zero-shot cloning (3s ref) + text voice design. 0.6B/1.7B models. 10 languages. Apache 2.0. 10.5k stars. (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/QwenLM/Qwen3-TTS Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceApache-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars14418 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-03-17 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)0 GBP (Apache 2.0). GPU for 1.7B: 0-2,400 GBP. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
watch
Conclusion
Technically superior to Dia. Apache 2.0. First evaluation candidate if we ever need TTS.
Limits for us
TTS not core. Chinese accent in English is quality issue. GPU required.
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
4
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.7

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

0.5B/1.7B models. 8-16GB VRAM. Combines cloning + voice design. New but from major lab. Worth evaluating alongside Chatterbox. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2026-03-17; licence unchanged (Apache-2.0).]

MMX-CLI

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

MiniMax official CLI: mmx text/image/video/speech/music/vision/search. 30+ voice TTS, text-to-image, async video gen. MCP-free shell commands. Ships SKILL.md for agent self-learning. (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/MiniMax-AI/cli Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceMIT (README); no licence file at repo root (2026-10-20) Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree CLI; MiniMax API Token Plan required as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars2221 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-10 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Two-year cost (GBP)MiniMax Token Plan ~GBP 30-100/month. Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
skip
Conclusion
Nice multimodal wrapper but not relevant. Zero Claude Code overlap. Skip.
Limits for us
Zero coding capability. API lock-in. China-hosted. TTS covered by Chatterbox+Kokoro.
Lock-in risk
high
Integration hours (estimate)
2
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.0

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

Multimodal media CLI (text, image, video, TTS, music). NOT a Claude Code competitor. All capability requires MiniMax API. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2026-10-19; no LICENSE file at root; README/manifest says MIT.]

ElevenLabs (Eleven v3 + Multilingual v2 + Flash/Turbo)

freemiumnot runnable on gaents yet

ElevenLabs provides production-grade text-to-speech, voice cloning, dubbing, and speech-to-text via API and web app. TTS supports 70+ languages with emotional control via audio tags (e.g., [excited], [whispers], [angry]). Voice cloning lets users create custom voices from 30-second to multi-minute samples. Dubbing translates and lip-syncs video across languages. Conversational AI product packages STT + LLM + TTS... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://elevenlabs.io Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licenceproprietary Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classproprietary Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typefreemium Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceCONFIRMED 2026-10-19: Free $0 (10k credits/mo); Starter $6 (30k); Creator $22 (121k; $11 first month only); Pro $99 (600k); Scale $299 (1.8M, 3 seats); Business $990 (6M, 10 seats); Enterprise custom. Annual = monthly x 10. Effective ~$0.17-$0.36 per 1k characters. as of 2026-10-19 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-19date written in Scout's pricing text
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
consider
Lock-in risk
medium
Integration hours (estimate)
4
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.5

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout tested it (untested-by-scout, 2026-09-14): Voice-B candidate for the Bitcoin V3 bake-off against Kokoro am_adam. NOT RUN — recorded so the un-run state is explicit rather than looking like an oversight. Sign-up is open ask #1 on the menu's bill/key table.

Scout's notes

Strongest end-to-end voice vendor in 2026 but does NOT displace ADOPT-NOW Chatterbox + Kokoro for org agent voices. Eleven v3 (GA 2026-03-14) supports audio tags for emotional control, dialogue mode, 70+ languages, NOT real-time. Flash v2.5 <75ms latency for conversational. Multilingual v2 = workhorse narration. Voice cloning available (Instant clone Starter+; Professional clone Creator+). Conversational AI / Voice Agents = separate product. Worth a CONSIDER for premium persona lane (Hermes/Sentinel personas) only. SPARK pupils: EVALUATE for Afrikaans children's voices (pilot needed); POPIA path via EU residency + Zero Retention Mode + Enterprise DPA — no SA residency offered. [2026-10-19T23:00Z cloud refresh: 2026-10-19: stored 'Creator $11' was the first-month 50% discount; list price is $22/month.] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class proprietary from ElevenLabs Terms 5(a); api_or_webhooks from the help centre (third-party services call the ElevenLabs API with your key); data_export false because the help centre says voice clones cannot be downloaded or exported (generated audio can still be downloaded). self_hostable left out.]

franken_tts

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

TTS with fast custom kernels. ARM-only. Ships NEGATIVE_EVIDENCE.md -- a dated ledger of optimisations that FAILED, with cpu_features + fixture_sha256 + rule that inherited results never support a perf claim. (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/dicklesworthstone/franken_tts Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceMIT (with OpenAI/Anthropic Restricted-Parties rider — Doodle 2026-08-23 read: likely non-binding on customers, verify before vendoring/redistributing) Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classsource-available Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
GitHub stars48 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-10 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
skip
Lock-in risk
high
Integration hours (estimate)
999

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

PATTERN TO STEAL: NEGATIVE_EVIDENCE.md -- anti-magic-number discipline written down. Directly copyable for our own performance work. Added to lessons this session. · 2026-09-14 LEX RULING (licence cleared): MCL is a CUSTOMER of Anthropic, NOT a Restricted Party under the OpenAI/Anthropic rider. Buyer-seller is not agency, not direction, and not 'for the benefit of' on any construction surviving commercial common sense (Rainy Sky v Kookmin [2011] UKSC 50; contra proferentem per Investors Compensation Scheme [1998]; noscitur a sociis). Licence VALID for our use. Confidence HIGH. Full ruling: ~/Projects/lex/outbox/2026-09-14-scout-anthropic-rider-ruling.md. CARVE-OUTS (not live, recorded so a future audit need not rebuild them): (1) a contractor/reseller/JV engagement WITH Anthropic or OpenAI would engage the rider for that engagement's workload; (2) redistribution TO a Restricted Party as end recipient is void. [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2026-10-17; licence unchanged (MIT).] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Rider check 2026-10-20: LICENSE at HEAD of dicklesworthstone/franken_tts is "MIT License (with OpenAI/Anthropic Rider)". licence_class set to source-available under the session-3 brief's definition (use restricted for named parties). This is an agent-chose reading, ruling null. `type` left for Scout. See docs/restricted-party-rider-2026-10-20.md.]

edge-tts

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Single-file Python client for Microsoft's Edge read-aloud service, giving access to the Azure Neural voice set with no key and no account. Cleaner than Kokoro on some accents — en-US-AndrewNeural and en-US-ChristopherNeural in particular. Emits word-boundary data alongside the audio, so it hands back a word-level SRT for free. (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/rany2/edge-tts Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
LicenceLGPL-3.0 (MIT for src/edge_tts/srt_composer.py only) Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Licence classcopyleft Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
PriceFree (no API key, no account) as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars12546 as of 2026-11-09 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout patch_history (github_stars changed)
Last commit2026-10-14 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-11-09Scout last_verified

Scout's judgement

Verdict
adopt
Limits for us
Dependency on an undocumented Microsoft endpoint — availability risk, not licence risk. No voice cloning, no fine control beyond rate/volume/pitch. Repo has been idle since March 2026, which matters more than usual for a tool whose job is to track someone else's private API.
Lock-in risk
medium
Integration hours (estimate)
1

Credited to Scout (2026-11-09, Scout last_verified). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

TUNABLES: · --voice — default en-US-EmmaMultilingualNeural. CHANGE: Video's picks are en-US-AndrewNeural and en-US-ChristopherNeural for documentary tone. `edge-tts --list-voices` enumerates the full set. · --rate — default +0%, takes a signed percentage. THE narration-length knob and the thing edge-tts has that Kokoro does not: ±10% is transparent to the ear and is the cheapest way to land a beat on its target duration without re-authoring the copy or post-hoc atempo. · --volume (+0%) and --pitch (+0Hz) — pitch in particular is worth a small negative value for gravitas; leave volume alone and normalise in ffmpeg where the whole mix is visible. · --write-subtitles — ALWAYS TAKE IT. Word-boundary timings come out of the same call at no extra cost, which is a free caption-alignment pass and is a real part of the argument against paying for Descript. · --proxy for the case where the endpoint rate-limits an IP. CASCADE: voice, rate, pitch belong in the same voice-profile config as Kokoro's voice selection, so swapping engines for an A/B is one setting rather than a rewrite of the narration step. [2026-10-19T22:08Z cloud refresh: Q4-2026 review: licence read from LICENSE at HEAD. Last commit 2026-10-14. Microsoft-terms caveat in earlier notes still applies. Verdict unchanged.] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from LICENSE (LGPL-3.0; MIT for one file). self_hostable = library you install (it still calls Microsoft's online Edge TTS service). api_or_webhooks left out (no documented Python API section in README). data_export n/a.]

Gemini 3.8 Flash TTS

commercialnot runnable on gaents yet

Google TTS; #2 on Artificial Analysis voice arena (ElevenLabs v3 #17). (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/speech-generation Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licenceproprietary API Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classproprietary Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typecommercial Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceCONFIRMED 2026-10-19: paid tier per 1M tokens: input $0.50 (text) through 2026-12-31, $1.00 from 2027-01-01; output $9.00 (audio) through 2026-12-31, $18.00 from 2027-01-01. Free tier available. Paid-tier data not used to improve products. as of 2026-10-19 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-19date written in Scout's pricing text
Self-hostableno Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
consider
Reasoning (de-assume)
Facts from one triage pass; re-verify the price/stars before acting.
Limits for us
Voice cloning needs the speaker's consent recording; arena ranks via press.

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

See research/tweet-triage-2026-09-29-scout.md for sources. [2026-10-19T23:00Z cloud refresh: 2026-10-19: stored prices confirmed on ai.google.dev pricing page. Also listed: Gemini 3.8 Flash-Lite TTS, output $6.00 (audio) per 1M tokens.] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from Gemini API terms (no reverse engineering/extraction; closed service); self_hostable false: hosted Gemini API, no self-hosted edition offered on the speech-generation docs page; api_or_webhooks from the TTS docs. data_export n/a (stateless compute API).]

VoiceStudio

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Local voice studio on OmniVoice; 50.9K stars (tweet's 19.4K stale). (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/debpalash/VoiceStudio Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceAGPL-3.0 (engines vary) Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classcopyleft Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Pricefree, local as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars110759 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-15 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
evaluate
Reasoning (de-assume)
Facts from one triage pass; re-verify the price/stars before acting.
Limits for us
Quality vs ElevenLabs unmeasured; AGPL.

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

See research/tweet-triage-2026-09-29-scout.md for sources. [2026-10-20T01:33Z cloud refresh: type None -> open-source (license text: AGPL; rule set agent-chose 2026-10-20, Adam to rule)] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from LICENSE and LICENSE-NOTICE.md (AGPL-3.0-only; engines vary); self_hostable from install docs; api_or_webhooks from README (local API and MCP); data_export n/a.]

OmniVoice (k2-fsa)

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

Open TTS engine under VoiceStudio. (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/k2-fsa/OmniVoice Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceApache-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Pricefree, local as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars16606 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-09 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
evaluate
Reasoning (de-assume)
Facts from one triage pass; re-verify the price/stars before acting.
Limits for us
Quality unmeasured by us.

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

See research/tweet-triage-2026-09-29-scout.md for sources. [2026-10-20T01:33Z cloud refresh: type None -> open-source (license text: Apache; rule set agent-chose 2026-10-20, Adam to rule)] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from LICENSE (Apache-2.0); self_hostable and api_or_webhooks from README; data_export n/a (model).]

VoxCPM2

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

See research/tweet-triage-2026-10-14-scout.md (section for VoxCPM2). (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/OpenBMB/VoxCPM Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceApache-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree (GPU for real-time) as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars42487 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-09 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
evaluate
Reasoning (de-assume)
One triage pass; re-verify stars, licence and price before acting.
Limits for us
See research/tweet-triage-2026-10-14-scout.md (section for VoxCPM2).

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

Merged from research/tweet-triage-2026-10-14-scout.md by merge_triage_table.py. [2026-10-20T01:33Z cloud refresh: type None -> open-source (license text: Apache; rule set agent-chose 2026-10-20, Adam to rule)] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Fact fields 2026-10-20: licence_class from LICENSE and README (weights and code Apache-2.0); self_hostable and api_or_webhooks from README (pip package); data_export n/a (model).]

Podcastfy

open-sourcenot runnable on gaents yet

See research/tweet-triage-2026-10-18-scout.md (section for Podcastfy). (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/souzatharsis/podcastfy Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
LicenceApache-2.0 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Licence classpermissive Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at
PriceFree (self-host); LLM + TTS costs pass through as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
GitHub stars6807 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-05-04 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-23T13:15ZScout patch_history.at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
consider
Reasoning (de-assume)
One triage pass; re-verify stars, licence and price before acting.
Limits for us
See research/tweet-triage-2026-10-18-scout.md (section for Podcastfy).

Credited to Scout (2026-10-23T13:15Z, Scout patch_history.at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's notes

Merged from research/tweet-triage-2026-10-18-scout.md by merge_triage_table.py. [2026-10-20T01:33Z cloud refresh: type None -> open-source (license text: Apache; rule set agent-chose 2026-10-20, Adam to rule)] [2026-10-23T13:15Z cloud refresh: Sweep 2026-10-20: last commit 2026-05-04; licence unchanged (Apache-2.0).]

Piper (OHF-Voice/piper1-gpl)

Why this link: the API's job list (GET /v1/jobs, read 2026-11-19T06:07:32Z) names this item as the job's source (proven_item_id).

Piper is a fast, local neural text-to-speech engine. This repo is where development of rhasspy/piper moved; it now lives under the Open Home Foundation. It embeds espeak-ng for phonemization (which is why it is GPL, not MIT like the old repo). It ships as a pip package with a command-line tool, a Python API, a small HTTP server (port 5000 by default, with a web page), a C/C++ library (libpiper) and voice-training... (Scout's description)

Facts Scout recorded
Source URLhttps://github.com/OHF-Voice/piper1-gpl Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at
LicenceGPL-3.0-or-later Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at
Licence classcopyleft Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at
Typeopen-source Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at
PriceCONFIRMED 2026-10-20: free. 'pip install piper-tts'; licence GPL-3.0 (COPYING) and 'GPL-3.0-or-later' on PyPI. No paid tier. Voices are separate downloads, each with its own licence in its MODEL_CARD. as of 2026-10-20 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20date written in Scout's pricing text
GitHub stars6291 as of: no date recorded for this field Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at; no date recorded for this field itself
Last commit2026-11-13 Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at
Self-hostableyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at
API or webhooksyes Scout, alternatives.json v3.72026-10-20Scout evidence.read_at

Scout's judgement

Verdict
skip
Reasoning (de-assume)
Cloud research pass 2026-10-19; re-verify price and licence before acting.
Limits for us
Same engine as the 'Piper TTS' row, which is skip: Chatterbox and Kokoro are already adopt-now for TTS, and Piper's voices are pre-trained only (no cloning) and sound less natural. The licence moved from MIT to GPL-3.0, which matters only if we ship it inside something we distribute. The docs say 'Piper is intended for personal use and text to speech research only' and some voices have restrictive licences, so each voice's MODEL_CARD must be checked. The README says the Open Home Foundation 'is looking for maintainers for Piper'. Compiled executables have not yet been ported from the old repo (docs/PLANS.md).
Lock-in risk
low
Integration hours (estimate)
2
Feature overlap (Scout's estimate)
0.3

Credited to Scout (2026-10-20, Scout evidence.read_at). gaents does not score items.

Scout's evidence (7 quotes)
Scout's notes

Added as the named successor of 'Piper TTS': the archived rhasspy/piper README says 'Development has moved: https://github.com/OHF-Voice/piper1-gpl'. Facts: repo last commit 2026-10-17; piper-tts 1.8.0 on PyPI uploaded 2026-09-04. Agent judgements: verdict 'skip', the same as the predecessor row, because it is the same engine and the predecessor's skip reason (Kokoro/Chatterbox adopt-now cover our TTS needs; lower quality; no cloning) still holds. The successor is actively maintained, so this is a fit verdict, not a staleness verdict. Scout may prefer 'watch' as the brief's default. integration_hours 2, lock_in_risk low and feature_overlap 0.3 copied from the Piper TTS row. data_export left out: a local engine holds no user data. two_year_cost_gbp: not computed: cost.two_year_basis is unruled.